J. Mark McKinzie


Assistant:  Christina L. Bowles



From his law office in Indianapolis, attorney Mark McKinzie utilizes his more than 40 years of experience in the areas of:

  • First and third party insurance defense litigation
  • Insurance regulatory and coverage issues
  • Commercial litigation
  • Construction litigation
  • Business & corporate law
  • Business contract drafting, and negotiating
  • Business entity selection
  • Contract disputes
  • Noncompetition agreements, and

to provide counsel to and advocacy on behalf of his clients. Mark understands the importance of cost-effective representation of his clients’ interests. He identifies key issues and approaches resolving them with a view toward avoiding litigation which often can be more costly and time consuming for the litigants than initially anticipated.

Where reasonable resolution cannot be obtained, Mark aggressively protects and promotes his clients’ interests and goals. In pursuing a counterclaim for a business owner against a major insurance company in Hamilton County, Indiana, Mark and his co-counsel secured the largest jury verdict for defamation against an American corporation in United States history.

Mark joined Riley Bennett Egloff LLP as a Partner more than 19 years ago, after a distinguished career in corporate insurance law, rising to be Senior VP, General Counsel, and Secretary for the Meridian Insurance Companies overseeing the claims and claim litigation functions, all 1st party litigation, including any allegation of bad faith by the company and serving in that position prior to the company’s sale and merger with State Auto Insurance of Columbus, Ohio.

With his business and legal background and extensive and varied experience, having represented plaintiffs and defendants in a wide range of practice areas, Mark possesses and consistently demonstrates keen insight and pragmatic, resourceful solutions beneficial to the parties.

Community Activity

  • Our Lady of Mount Carmel
    • Parishioner, Member, 1988 – present
  • Valleybrook Homeowners’ Association
    • Member, 2006 – Present
    • President, 2006 – 2018
  • Woodland Country Club
    • President, 2006
    • Board Member, 2004 – 2006

Representative Matters

  • Mark has been lead counsel in more than twenty-five (25) jury trials and has represented clients in numerous hearings in front of various regulatory bodies.
  • Defended gentlemen’s club in dram shop action involving multiple fatalities.
  • Defended insurance company’s interests in regulatory dispute over whether the Department of Insurance or the Department of Finance had primary regulatory jurisdiction in regulating the client’s product.
  • Developed innovative process for restoration contractor: sought and secured numerous Court Ordered Appraisal Process Orders, working with contractor and insurance company, when there was a failure to reach an agreed amount of damages for property claim where coverage and causation were not in dispute.
  • Guided an investor in publicly traded insurance company to receive necessary regulatory approvals in five (5) states.
  • Defended a municipal water company in personal injury action alleging tainted water supply.
  • Defended insurance company in targeted Insurance Department Market Conduct Examination and negotiated a significantly reduced Agreed Settlement from Initial Order.
  • Defended insurance company in 1st party Bad Faith Claim and secured Summary Judgment for client.



  • Weighing the Costs and Benefits of Insurance Litigation,” 60th Annual Central Indiana Chapter of the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter Conferment Luncheon (October 2006)
  • “Potential Benefits of Self-Insurance,” Indiana Association of School Business Officials (IASBO) (2009)
  • Indianan Continuing Legal Education Forum, Indiana Insurance Law Symposium (2015)

Awards & Recognition

  • Best Lawyers in America, 2023
    • Insurance Law
    • Litigation — Construction
  • Indiana Super Lawyers, 2022 – present
    • Insurance Coverage
  • Martindale-Hubbell AV Rated, 2012 – present
  • Indiana Insurance Institute, 2003
    • Outstanding Support & Commitment Award
  • Indiana Insurance Guaranty Association’s Board of Directors, 1996 – 2000
    • Outstanding Leadership Award for four years as Chairman 
  • Insurance Institute of Indiana Legislative Study Committee, 1992 – 1994
    • Leadership Award for serving as Chairman
  • Indy Bar Foundation, 2015
    • Distinguished Fellow


  • Indiana State Bar Association
  • Indianapolis Bar Association
  • American Bar Association
    • Tort and Insurance Practice and Business Law Sections
  • Illinois State Bar Association
  • Defense Research Institute
  • Defense Trial Counsel of Indiana
  • Insurance Institute of Indiana Committees, including past Chairman of both Legislative Steering and Amicus Curiae Committees
  • Alliance of American Insurers Legal Committee
  • National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies Legal Committee
  • National Association of Independent Insurers Laws Committee
  • Founding Director of the Urban Insurance Partners Foundation
  • Member of the Indiana Insurance Guaranty Association Board of Directors
    • Chairman, 1996 – 2000

Bar and Court Admissions

  • Indiana, 1989
  • Illinois, 1979
  • U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana
  • U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit


  • Indiana University Maurer School of Law, JD, cum laude, 1978
  • University of Illinois, MBA with highest honors, 1976
  • University of Illinois, BS, Finance with high honors, 1974

Industries Served


Practice Areas

Business & Corporate Law
Business Litigation
Commercial Litigation
Government Law
Business Contract Drafting & Negotiation
Business Entity Selection & Formation
Business Contract Disputes
Non-competition Covenants
Shareholder & Partnership Disputes
Construction Litigation & Dispute Resolution
Construction Contract Drafting & Negotiation
Arbitration / Mediation / Alternative Dispute
Product Liability
Toxic Tort
Insurance Defense
Insurance Coverage
Insurance Regulation